Choosing a Pet Food in the Age of ChatGPT

AI tools can read an ingredient label in seconds, but what do they miss about the bigger picture?

When Monica Hacker asked ChatGPT which dog food to buy, Purina Pro Plan came first. She opened a fresh chat and asked again, then repeated the question a third time. The results were the same: Purina Pro Plan, followed by Hill’s and Royal Canin.

Hacker, a marketing consultant who helps brands appear in AI recommendations, published the results in November 2026. Her experiment covered five questions asked three times each. The cat-food answers produced the same leading brands as the dog-food answers, and the fresh-food questions returned the same four subscription companies. Nutramax’s Dasuquin led all three joint-supplement answers. For someone sorting through conflicting advice, that consistency can be reassuring, especially when the explanations point to nutrition expertise, feeding trials and veterinary recommendations.

Those are reasonable things to consider. The harder question is how much they tell you about the particular food you are buying, and whether it suits the animal you are feeding.

Every day, in the store and in our inbox, we hear the worry behind these AI searches. People want to know whether an expensive food is worth buying, whether another supplement would help, or whether something in their veterinarian’s notes deserves more attention. A chatbot gives them somewhere to begin, often at an hour when no one is available to ask. The answer may help them prepare for a conversation, but it may also leave out information that would change the decision.

Looking beyond the recommendation

Qualified nutrition staff and published research are good reasons to consider a food, and feeding animals the finished product can reveal things recipe calculations cannot. Hacker’s test did not compare the foods or measure how dogs fared on them, however, and it could not establish why ChatGPT selected those brands.

“Complete and balanced” is a useful place to begin, because the phrase means something specific. According to FDA’s explanation, a food must meet established nutrient requirements or pass a feeding trial using procedures set by the Association of American Feed Control Officials, known as AAFCO. The label identifies the life stage the food supports, such as growth or adult maintenance. What it does not describe is the manufacturer’s full research and testing program.

AAFCO’s adult-dog protocol materials, published with proposed updates in 2013, describe a trial starting with at least eight healthy dogs and lasting at least 26 weeks, or about six months. Weight checks, veterinary examinations and specified blood tests provide useful information about those dogs during that time. They cannot establish how every breed or individual will fare over a lifetime, or verify the nutrient content of every batch made afterward. Some companies conduct larger trials, longer studies and additional testing. When you contact a manufacturer, these questions can help you understand what it does:

  • Are the nutrient levels checked in the finished food? Ask whether the figures come from recipe calculations, lab testing, or both, and how many batches have been tested. Ingredients and manufacturing vary; AAFCO’s own laboratory guidance cautions that results from one batch may not represent the next. Find out how often testing continues.
  • Can you share a full nutrient analysis? The protein, fat, fiber and moisture figures on the bag tell only part of the story. Ask for the essential vitamins, minerals and amino acids, too. A typical analysis describes expected levels, calculated or based on testing. A certificate of analysis reports what a lab measured in a particular sample, so check which batch it represents and what was tested.
  • How do you check for bacteria and contaminants before food ships? Ask whether finished batches are held until test results arrive, which bacteria are tested for and what happens if a batch fails. A negative result cannot guarantee every portion is free of contamination, so ask about the company’s other safety measures as well.
  • Do you have digestibility data for this formula? How much of a nutrient a food contains is different from how much an animal can use. Ask what the company has measured in dogs eating this food.

These questions follow the emphasis on nutrient analysis, manufacturing controls and research in the World Small Animal Veterinary Association’s food-selection guidelines. A company may keep results confidential while still explaining its testing, regardless of where it appears on a chatbot’s list.

Accounting for the dog’s whole diet

The chart on the bag has no way to account for the chew after a walk, the treats used during training, or the topper added at dinner. All of them count toward daily intake, which is one reason feeding amounts need to be considered alongside the dog’s condition. Weight alone will not tell you whether a dog or cat carries too much fat. Ask your veterinarian to assess body condition and show you how to follow it at home; the WSAVA nine-point scale considers the ribs, waist and abdominal shape, with four to five ideal for dogs and cats.

Feeding instructions give you a starting amount, as AAFCO’s consumer guidance explains. When changing formulas, check the calories per cup or can again, even within the same brand: the same scoop of a different food may provide more or fewer calories.

Before adding a supplement, consider what you want it to help with, then write down everything your dog already receives, including amounts and frequency, and bring the labels to your veterinarian. A multivitamin and a fortified topper may already supply some of the same nutrients. Adding another product can increase the total without making that overlap obvious. Excesses of vitamins A or D and minerals such as zinc or copper can cause harm, although the risks depend on the nutrient, dose and duration. Merck’s veterinary reference describes those differences, and selenium can also be toxic in excess.

Questions that need veterinary attention

A possible poisoning cannot wait for the same kind of research. Grapes and raisins can cause severe kidney injury, with no established amount that can be assumed safe for every dog; a previous exposure without apparent harm does not make another one safe. Cornell’s veterinary guidance recommends contacting a veterinarian or animal poison control immediately after ingestion, even if the dog seems fine. If your dog eats grapes, raisins or another potentially toxic substance, make that call rather than waiting for symptoms or comparing answers online.

Medical records raise a different concern. Clinical notes often use shorthand, and they may leave out conversations, observations or reasons a test was deferred. When a chatbot is asked what the veterinarian “missed,” it may interpret that missing context as a mistake, even while explaining the medical terms correctly. You should be able to question your pet’s care. Ask the veterinarian to explain the finding that concerns you and how it affected the plan; if concerns remain, a second veterinary opinion can consider the records alongside your pet’s history and examination.

Before uploading a chart, remove personal details such as your name, address, phone number and financial information, and review the service’s privacy terms and account settings. HIPAA does not cover your pet’s veterinary records, although other confidentiality and privacy requirements apply, as the AAHA/AVMA guidance explains.

AI can help you prepare for those conversations if you give it a specific task. For example: “My dog is a seven-year-old neutered male, 58 pounds, with a recent body condition score of six out of nine. He eats [food and amount], plus [treats, toppers and supplements]. Help me prepare questions for my veterinarian about feeding amounts and supplements, and for the manufacturer about how this food is tested.” You can then take the questions to people who can explain the testing or assess your dog.

At NorthPoint Pets in Cheshire, bring us your food label, treat and supplement list, and veterinarian’s recommendations. We’ll review what your dog or cat eats, help you get answers about the manufacturer’s testing, and explain how the options fit your pet, your budget and your routine. We don’t diagnose, treat, or replace veterinary care. We provide nutrition education and product guidance.

This information is for educational purposes only and does not replace veterinary medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Every pet is unique. If your pet has a diagnosed condition, work with your veterinarian on dietary and supplement decisions.

Sources

  • Monica Hacker. The ChatGPT Pet Index. November 7, 2026.
  • FDA. “Complete and Balanced” Pet Food.
  • AAFCO. 2013 Proposed Updates to Feeding Protocols; Nutritional Labeling; Selecting the Right Pet Food.
  • WSAVA. Guidelines on Selecting Pet Foods and nine-point Body Condition Score chart.
  • Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine. Grape and Raisin Toxicity.
  • Merck Veterinary Manual. References on vitamin, mineral and selenium toxicity.
  • AAHA/AVMA. Telehealth Guidelines: Security.

Sources are linked in the relevant passages above.